Rabbit’s Reviews #416: Mash Kyrielight (Shielder) – Part 1

22whiterabbit22
Before I get into the meat of this review, some expectation-setting. First, why a Mash review now of all times? Mash is FGO’s first Servant, a major story character everyone has access to. As FGO’s story has progressed, Mash has periodically gotten buffs, updates, and in some cases entirely new skillsets. With FGO’s main story nearing its conclusion in the Japanese version of the game, it’s looking like Mash has gotten her final update, and with that in mind, I thought it was time to look back and re-evaluate Mash. This isn’t something I normally do for Servants—it’s just not feasible timewise to re-review every Servant whenever they get buffed—but Mash has changed drastically over time and Mash of all Servants deserves a second look.
This three-part review will cover the entirety of Mash’s kit as it stands now in JP. It shouldn’t come as a surprise that Mash continues to get updates as the story goes on, but consider this a mild spoiler warning—I will be covering gameplay content that won’t be available in NA for some time. All of the information I’ll be covering is plainly available in FGO’s various wikis and will likely be unavoidable in gameplay discussion going forward. Even as someone relatively sensitive to spoilers, I don’t personally find the mechanical contents of Mash’s kit to be a spoiler, and even if they were, my dancing around them in these reviews probably wouldn’t do much for helping someone avoid these details for the two years it will take for NA to catch up. As such, these reviews will contain “spoilers” in the sense that they will reference mechanical content not yet available in NA. This has always been true of my reviews, but this is a reminder in case you’d rather try to avoid any details about future Mash updates.
That said, there are details surrounding the timing of and reasons for Mash’s updates that are narrative spoilers. I will be avoiding these details entirely. You can expect these reviews to focus exclusively on Mash’s current gameplay capabilities,  without any acknowledgment of their surrounding narrative context (except for some notes about timing which are necessary for evaluating the usefulness of some tools).
In short, if you consider the details of a Servant’s kit to be spoilers, you might want to skip this three-part review and close the page here. Otherwise, you should be safe.
If you’re still reading beyond this point, I’m assuming you’re okay with discussion of Mash’s gameplay as it stands in FGO JP in May 2025.
This brings me to the other reason I’m re-evaluating Mash. Just like Lostbelt gave Mash a completely new kit many years ago, Ordeal Call has given Mash a third completely unique kit. While I could review that version of Mash alone, a clever friend of mine observed that, because Mash’s skillsets are mutually-exclusive, they can’t be evaluated in a vacuum. If you choose to bring one particular version of Mash to a fight, you necessarily cannot bring the other two. In order to give a holistic view of Mash’s strengths and weaknesses, it’s important to consider not only what each of Mash’s kits offer, but also what you give up in exchange for those benefits.
We’ll start with Mash’s original kit. Once upon a time, base Mash was a great free support, offering strong partywide protection, some charge, and some damage buffing—to the point that there was some annoyance when the Lostbelt chapters forced Mash into (what seemed at first to be) an inferior kit. As we’ve gotten more and more free support options—and as Mash’s alternative kits have improved—this has become less true. That said, base Mash still holds up pretty well as a defensive support, and she definitely still has her place.
Mash Kyrielight
loader-2
loader-2
As one might expect, Mash has a defense-leaning stat spread, with mid-low attack and mid-high health relative to SRs in general. There are no other Shielders to compare her to at the moment, but compared to all Servants she’s skewed towards defense. Mash does have the small advantage of being able to reach level 90 without grails. This doesn’t help Mash’s ultimate statline if you choose to grail her anyway, but it does mean her stats are better than a typical SR’s if left ungrailed. It’s also worth noting that, as a Shielder, Mash never gets class advantage or disadvantage. This means she can safely be used in any fight, but she also never benefits from counterclassing. I would call this a negative on-balance—FGO favors specialization and Shielders are the ultimate generalists—but given Mash’s supportive focus it doesn’t particularly matter.
Mash’s internals, meanwhile, are pretty unimpressive. She has extremely low hit-counts, as is typical of early FGO Servants. Her Arts card NP gain is slightly lower than average relative to her deck, and her Quick card is really bad. She’s also terrible at active star gen due to her deck and hit-counts.
For passives, Mash gets Magic Resistance, for occasionally avoiding debuffs, as well as a low level of Riding, which might as well not exist considering Mash’s terrible Quick card. She also gets a unique passive called Stargazer’s Journey, which boosts the party’s bond gain in Lostbelt main story quests. This doesn’t impact her performance, of course, but it’s a small incentive to bring her along for the relevant story fights.
Mana Loading is Mash’s best append, making it easier to get early access to her NP. Skill Reload is also actually pretty good for her—Mash’s whole role is to keep the party alive, so she’s fairly likely to stick around to a second buff cycle, and Skill Reload can get Mash’s defensive buffs online a turn earlier, which can be critical in harder fights. Aside from that, Mash gets a special version of the anti-class attack up append that applies to all Extra classes, rather than just to one class, which is pretty cool in theory but has essentially no impact on this particular kit. Mash’s other two appends don’t help her base kit at all, really.
loader-2
Mash’s mat asks are extremely easy, needing only five of a host of early-FGO mats. This is natural, of course, given that Mash released at FGO’s launch. Especially this late in FGO’s life cycle, there’s no reason not to max out her skills—she’s more than strong enough to justify the investment and it’s not hard to do so.
Base Mash’s skillset is a bit plain by modern Servant standards, but all three of the skills are reasonably useful and have a clear purpose, so it’s still a solid skillset overall. Recommended skill order is 2>1>3.
loader-2
Honorable Wall of Snowflakes is a simple and reasonably powerful defensive buff, giving a 20% defense buff for 3 turns along with a one-time-only 2000 HP damage cut. The damage cut is so large that, especially with Mash’s NP also in play, it’s likely to negate all damage from a single non-Noble-Phantasm attack, especially if the Servant getting hit has defensive class advantage. The defense buff, meanwhile, isn’t all that strong on its own, but defense buffs are functionally more powerful the more of them you can stack, and this pairs very very well with Mash’s NP. Given this skill’s five-turn cooldown, it’s active more often than not, and you can afford to just use it any time it’s available, making for a nice boost to party survival.
loader-2
Obscurant Wall of Chalk is a targeted invuln and 20% battery. Once upon a time these were both very rare effects. Having targeted charge and a targeted invuln on a free unit was really really good! Now, though, there are better options for both, and being stuck in the same place is not ideal—you don’t often want the battery and the invuln at the same time, and you end up being forced to choose between using the battery optimally or not benefitting from the battery in service of saving the invuln for when you need it. The skill is also on a pretty long cooldown relative to its strength. This isn’t a bad skill, to be clear—both effects are useful—but it’s very much “year 1 FGO strong” rather than “modern FGO strong.” Mash gets good use out of this skill, but it’s more than a little dated.
loader-2
Shield of Rousing Resolution is a one-turn taunt that also drastically increases Mash’s NP gain. This helps offset Mash’s weak cards and can get her easier access to an NP, especially considering that the NP gain buff applies to both offensive and defensive NP gain. Mash draws fire to herself, and if the incoming attacks have a half-decent hit-count they’re likely to fill Mash’s NP gauge completely. Taunts are also a strong form of defensive utility in general, especially for “touch of death” type fights where enemies regularly crit for massive damage. Mash can also pair this with Obscurant Wall of Chalk to protect against a single-target Noble Phantasm or a turn of deadly crits. As with the other two skills, this is a bit plain by modern FGO standards, but it fits cleanly with Mash’s other tools and is very useful in practice.
loader-2
Lord Camelot is a simple but very strong Noble Phantasm, granting a hefty defense boost and a solid damage cut to the entire party for three turns. Especially with other defense buffs in play, Lord Camelot can reduce most normal attack damage to zero, significantly increasing the party’s survival. Mash can also pretty reliably keep this effect active with smart skill use and the right teammates. Most other stall strategies have fallen by the wayside in a world with Castoria, but Mash used to be one of the best stall supports out there, and she still works if you choose to use her.
Lord Camelot also grants a 30% attack buff to Mash’s teammates, meaning she isn’t entirely limited to defensive support. This isn’t a particularly large damage increase, but it’s certainly better than nothing, and having more damage for your DPS means you don’t have to stall as long, which is very much appreciated.
Mash is a stall support. You bring her when you need your team to survive a little longer than they would otherwise. If you’re building a Mash-centric team, you want to pair her with a damage-dealer and another stall-leaning support. Mash teams benefit strongly from additional defensive buffs, as the additive stacking of defense buffs means you can easily reduce incoming damage to zero. Waver and Reines are the classic options here, bringing partywide defense buffs reminiscent of Mash’s alongside some damage buffs. Jeanne is also a strong pick at higher NP levels—her NP gives a negligible defense buff at NP1, but especially at NP3 or higher she can meaningfully increase Mash’s defense-based survivability while also bringing healing and some party damage buffs. Lanling is another good option, leaning into damage cut rather than defense up, which is stronger against enemies that hit many times for low damage (such as bosses with AoE attacks).
For a damage-dealer, you’re ideally looking for someone who also brings defensive utility or healing. Munenori is a really good pick for single-target fights, for example, as his NP applies a three-turn attack down, and he can further reduce an enemy’s attack by 50% for a turn, fitting quite well with Mash’s tools. Jinako also works well, as she and Mash can stagger their taunts to regularly block ST Noble Phantasms. You can also consider someone like Berserker Castoria, who brings some NP charge tools, party protection, and very good damage. In general, Mash is a very flexible support. She’ll do best when paired with Servants who can complement her defensive utility, but she can work with just about anyone, especially when assisted by the right supports.
One important thing to consider is the question of why you would use this Mash specifically, considering that taking base Mash necessarily means you aren’t taking Mash’s other two forms. Relative to her other SR kit, this Mash is better for sustained fights, offering more party damage mitigation, more attack up for her allies, and more personal survivability. Mash’s other SR kit is focused on keeping your team alive just long enough in very dangerous situations, while this kit is focused on keeping your team alive forever in less-intense environments. In other words, base mash is better for long fights, while Mash’s other SR kit is better for short-to-mid-length fights.
Due to certain quirks of Mash’s third kit (which I’ll address in detail when I get to it), base Mash is very slightly better at stacking defense buffs specifically. She’s not necessarily a stronger defensive support overall, but if you’re fully leaning into mitigating damage via defense up and attack down, you might choose base Mash over her third kit. That said, the much more important reason you might use base Mash over Mash’s third kit is that base Mash has zero team cost, while the third kit has a team cost of 16. That’s a lot of extra team-building flexibility, and especially if all you need is some incidental defense, being able to slot in another powerful Servant or a top-end CE can be worth picking the “weaker” version of Mash.
If you want Mash to NP right away for immediate protection, Kaleidoscope is the way to go. Otherwise, you probably want either a star gen CE like 2030 for facilitating crits, or you want a CE that will help Mash consistently access her NP. I’m a big fan of Prisma Cosmos on Mash, personally, especially if I have a good way of getting her quick access to that first NP.
Your CC choices for Mash should be made in light of all three of her kits and how often you expect to use each of them. That said, if you’re prioritizing base Mash, defense-boosting and healing CCs can be good picks for keeping Mash alive longer. You can also give her the buff removal CCs for a bit of extra utility if you like.
Base Mash doesn’t really get any benefit from increased attack, but increased health can help her stick around longer for party survival reasons. There’s a world in which you want Mash to die to make room for another support and where having higher health gets in the way of this… but Mash has so many defensive tools that she’s not a good pick for strategies that rely on Servant deaths anyway, so this isn’t a big concern in my mind. Grails won’t have a huge impact on base Mash’s power, but a bit of extra survival can make the difference in a hard fight, and her kit is quite strong overall, so I’d say she’s a worthwhile grail target.
Mash is a very good defensive support, especially considering that she’s free. She is unfortunately unavailable in a number of story fights (due to being forced to use the most up-to-date version of her kit) but even in present-day FGO she can be helpful for challenge quests. Some elements of her kit are a bit dated or a bit undertuned relative to modern FGO when taken alone, but all of the elements of Mash’s kit work together as an elegant and coherent whole. If she wasn’t a zero-cost unit, she would be somewhat less impressive, but as a Servant you can slot into any team to work around cost limitations, and as a defensive support you can reliably build teams around, she holds up remarkably well, even today.
Also, I do appreciate that all three of Mash’s kits have clear reasons you would use them over the others. Even now, with two fancier and newer skillsets to pull on, there are still cases where you might take base Mash instead. She still works for a lot of content, she enables stall strategies that are hard to leverage with anyone else, and she’s entirely free. Base Mash is still a great Servant, even as we approach FGO’s tenth anniversary.
To be continued in part 2 and part 3!