Witch on the Holy Night Collab - Tier List Change Log

Introduction

• The latest Witch on the Holy Night collab event introduces new Servants:
• Aoko Aozaki
• Alice Kuonji
• Soujyuro Sizuki
• Additionally, multiple Servants received upgrades during various campaigns:
• CBC 2026:
• Charlemagne
• Bradamante
• Ordeal Call II Id Chapter Release:
• Jeanne d'Arc
• Jeanne d'Arc (Alter)
• Witch on the Holy Night Collab:
• Asagami Fujino
• Calamity Jane

• All Servants that were discussed for tier placement or movement are detailed below.

5 Star Servants

Tier A+

Alice joins the roster during the Witch on the Holy Night collab's second half as an AoE Quick Caster. She is fully capable of looping her NP with Quick Support, and her NP applies Sure Hit before dealing bonus damage to both Human Trait and Human Attribute enemies, which are relatively common. To further support her NP looping capability, she has a 50% NP charge skill for herself, a separate 20% NP charge skill for herself, and a 3-turn NP Gain buff for the party. Offensively, she has Quick, Arts, and ATK buffs in addition to her trait based damage bonuses. Her defensive capability is where she sets herself apart as a Quick Servant. She has a unique ability, Substitute, which acts similarly to Anti-Enforcement Defense, but is unremovable and comes on a short 2-turn cooldown for 1 hit across 2 turns. This skill is instead limited by the fact that it consumes 1 Robin Counter per use, and she starts at 13 when she enters battle. Her 20% NP charge is notably also on the same 2-turn cooldown. Additionally, her NP's ability to inflict Stun with a 60% chance on all targets also indirectly increases the survivability of her team by locking down the enemy team. Outside of these, she also has a DEF buff and debuffs Crit Rate for the enemies with her NP. Overall, her skill set makes her very capable in both farming contexts as well as in more challenging encounters.

4 Star Servants

Tier A

Soujyuro is the welfare Servant of the Witch on the Holy Night collab event, and is a single target Buster Berserker with self sacrifice capabilities. His NP buffs his ATK and applies both Ignore Invincible and the rare Ignore Damage Cut effect before applying damage, and deals bonus damage if enemies have any DEF Up buffs active. Afterwards, his NP inflicts Death on himself. The rest of his kit also contains a mix of unique effects. He has a special Evade that only works for lethal damage for 5 hits across 3 turns. He also has a Crit Damage buff that increases the number of stacks active the lower his HP, and a skill that changes all of his Command Cards into one color of choice after a 1-turn delay. Additionally, he does have an NP charge skill, but its effect is to double his current NP charge value rather than to give him any flat amount of charge. All these combined make him also a potent user of any Guts CEs or supports, which would let him take maximum advantage of his Crit Damage buffs. Alternatively, Masters may opt to let his NP's Death effect occur so that Servants in the backline can be rotated to the front row more quickly, effectively acting as an Order Change. Since he is a Welfare Servant that enables many team compositions in unique ways, Masters will be well-served if they choose to obtain Soujyuro.

Tier List Movements

5 Star Servants

Tier B -> B+

Bradamante also receives an upgrade during the CBC 2026 event, where her third skill gets an improvement. The NP charge she gains from the skill is improved from 10-20% up to 20-30%, and she additionally gains new effects, including anti-Earth bonus damage +20-30% for 3 turns, and increased NP Gain for herself +20-30% for 3 turns. Two of these effects ease her NP looping setups, making NP refund a bit easier. The anti-Earth bonus gives her a bit of bonus damage against certain enemies, and Earth attribute is relatively common so it will see decently frequent application. As result, her tier was given a small bump.

Tier B+ -> B+

Jalter gets the coveted NP charge skill upgrade with the release of Ordeal Call II: Id. Her third skill now can give 30-50% NP charge for herself on demand with the upgrade. While the upgrade is simple, since it is on a 6-turn cooldown skill, she now can do 3-turn NP looping with 2x Koyanskaya / Oberon and a starting NP gauge CE, giving her great performance in 1/1/1 waves or against a chunky boss that needs multiple NP hits or has break bars. However, unfortunately the Buster buff part of her third skill still only lasts 1 turn unfortunately, which prevents two stacks of it from being active on the third turn of a 2x Koya/Oberon loop setup. Although some believe this was worth a tier bump, overall, the general agreement was that this buff more of a "keep up with the meta" buff that solidifies her current placement.

4 Star Servants

Tier B -> B+

Calamity Jane also receives an upgrade during the Witch on the Holy Night collab event. Her first skill gets an upgrade where the Crit Rate debuff is increased from 9-19% to 20-30%, and gains an enemy party DEF debuff of 10-20% for 3 turns, along with 10 Stars on demand, and a 30% chance of 10 more stars up to 4 times. This buff directly synergizes with her third skill's effects based on number of Stars, allowing her to roll the dice on trying to get more buffs to activate on skill 3. Even if it is not consistent, at the very least it makes her 3rd skill essentially guarantee the Crit Damage buff (10 Stars required). Unfortunately her buff rate success buff is tied to her 3rd skill too, so she has to choose to either gamble at lower odds to get more buffs from her 3rd skill, or use her 3rd skill first and then get more Stars. However, overall it was agreed that this buff improves her supportive capacity, damage ceiling, and was worth a small tier bump.

Tier List Change Log History

See the full tier list change log history here.